Thursday, February 2, 2012

Your Words, Against Mine

After hearing about the other social movements in class, I came to an understanding that not all social action can be categorized as a social movement. For example, I came to the conclusion that the American Indiana Movement, since its origin in the 1960, did contain all elements of a social movement. It does not only maintain a well organized campaign, but it is also establishes a connection with the public. Its repertoire of using none electoral political activity, leads the organization to conduct different forms of protest. Finally, the AIM displays WUNC elements in their actions by displaying sober demeanor (Worthiness), creating banners and songs (Unity), petitions (Numbers), and resistance to oppression (Commitment). It is true that the AIM was more active and public in the 1960s and 1970s than it is today, but along the way it branched off into other sub-movements that protested for similar actions. Such can be the same in early stages of the Women's Movement that fought for equal rights in the public sphere. 


After class on Wednesday, I went to my volunteer site, which is the after school program La's Best in West Vernon elementary school in South Los Angeles, and had a similar, but heated argument about social movements with a co-worker. We argued about a movement that is recently happening in Mexico, in an effort to stop the drug cartel violence, which is largely affecting young children. I listened to her, but in the end was not able to maintain a mature conversation since she got very angry and walked away in the middle of our conversation. I merely explained to her the elements that characterized a social movement, and suggested that the movement might not yet be categorized as a social movement. It lacked WUNC displays, mostly in the Numbers category. In this protest, numbers had only reached about 1,000 people in one state of Mexico, a number i found very low in despite of the major issue. When I gave my opinion in suggesting it would take more time for this to become a social movement, I was met with anger and attitude. I the end of the conversation, I realized I had already made an enemy in my volunteer site, I just hope im wrong. I found it interesting how people want to know what categorizes a social movement, but in the end if they do not agree, your credibility is out the window in their eyes. Although this was not a positive conversation, I will continue to express my opinion and knowledge about what a social movement consists of. 


2 comments:

  1. Sorry to hear you had a run in at your internship site. I hope it blows over. If it escalates, let me know.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you. At this point I feel like im running the program since I've done almost everything.

    ReplyDelete